RSS

 

 

Why You Want a Healthy BMI


 By | June 25, 2012 | 27 Comments
 Category: General Wellness Healthy Diet

About 97 million adults in the U.S. are overweight or obese, according to the National Heart Lung and Blood Institute

I remember once hearing a joke that went something like this: Doctor says to patient, “Well, well. It seems that your weight is perfect. It just happens that you are eleven feet too short.”

If you’ve ever wondered about your weight (and who hasn’t?) as it relates to your height – if it’s a “healthy” weight – that’s where this fairly reliable indicator of body fatness comes in handy. BMI calculates how much you should weigh, based on your height. And although it cannot measure your body fat in a direct way – these other methods include skinfold measurements using calipers, underwater weighing, dual energy x-ray absorptiometry, or DXA – research has shown that BMI does correlate to direct measures of body fat and can be considered an alternative for other measures, which are typically costly and difficult to access. BMI measurement is inexpensive and easy for both clinicians and the general public to use to compare their own weight status to that of the general population.

However solid a measurement of body fatness BMI is, there are some considerations to take into account. Are you a woman? At the same BMI, women have more body fat than men. Perhaps you work out and lift weights regularly. You may have a high(er) BMI because of your increased muscle mass (muscle weighs more than fat). Are you getting on in years? Again, at the same BMI, older people tend to have more body fat than younger adults.

However a strong predictor, measuring BMI is only one way to assess your risk for diseases related to being overweight. The National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute guidelines also recommend looking at waist circumference and other risk factors, like high blood pressure or physical inactivity.

A BMI from 25.0 to 29.9 puts you in the “overweight” range, while a BMI greater than 30 will move you over the line, into the “obese” range.

It’s no news that excess weight is a health danger, increasing your risk of diseases and health conditions you’d rather avoid, including:

- Hypertension
- Coronary heart disease
- Type-2 diabetes
- Stroke
- Gallbladder disease
- Osteoarthritis
- High cholesterol & triglycerides
- Sleep apnea
- Respiratory problems
- Certain cancers, like breast, endometrial and colon

And speaking of being overweight, a May 8th article in the business section of The New York Times this year highlighted another risk associated with it; one I must admit I hadn’t thought of: some scientists and engineers are concerned about the safety of airplane seats for overweight passengers. The federal standards on the strength of the seats and seat belts (which were set more than 60 years ago) were designed for a passenger weighing 170 pounds. But since that time, Americans have put on some pounds; the average man today weighs nearly 194 pounds and the average woman, 165 pounds.  What’s even more frightening to realize is that, according to Robert Salzar, the principal scientist at the Center for Applied Biomechanics at the University of Virginia, it’s not just the seat occupant who may not be protected. If seats collapse and belts fail, passengers seated nearby might be put in danger as well, from “the unrestrained motion of the passenger.”

Yes, weight, like airplanes, is climbing to dizzying heights. But that certainly doesn’t mean we should throw up our hands in surrender. According to The Mayo Clinic, losing just five to ten percent of your body weight, if you are an obese person, can yield you significant health improvements. For a person weighing 250 pounds, that loss translates into a range of 12-25 pounds.

Here’s some even more encouraging news for us women of a certain age. When scientists followed a group of 102 healthy pre-menopausal, non-obese women between the ages of 47 and 55 for five years, they found that despite their changes in body composition and visceral abdominal fat (which oftentimes occurs with menopause), the women did not have an increased risk of heart disease. And since heart disease risk increases after menopause – and is the number one killer in this country – that’s somewhat comforting, don’t you think?  The study, published in the journal Menopause, stresses the importance of maintaining a healthy BMI in those pre-menopause years.

Simply put, that healthy BMI will set you up for a healthier heart.

Exercise is one guaranteed BMI Buster.

Curious about how to calculate your BMI? Click here.

 

 

Tagged with:

Bookmark and Share

 

 

 

27 thoughts on “Why You Want a Healthy BMI

Brette says:

I always felt BMI was not the most accurate measure because some people have bigger frames than others. And I also would really like someone to point out that weight is often very linked to genes. I do get tired of the guilt trip that discussion about BMI creates.

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    There are limitations with BMI, and although I’m not a healthcare professional, I do know that it’s one of the accepted and accurate ways to measure healthy weights. Waist circumference measurement is also an option. While there are many factors for overweight, including genetics, the ensuing health risks (like type-2 diabetes, heart disease and high blood pressure) are still present. I’m really glad you joined the discussion, Brette!

    Reply

     

     

Nancy Monson says:

Hmmmm…I never thought about the weight of other plane passengers being a safety hazard to me before. There are so many negative consequences of obesity for all of us, individually and as a society.

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    I agree, Nancy! I would never have considered that, either, until I read that interesting article. Makes you wonder how many other hidden dangers of obesity you would not even think about, doesn’t it?

    Reply

     

     

Kerri Fivecoat-Campbell says:

I’ve always heard about this BMI, but didn’t realize why it was so important, thanks for this post!

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    You are so welcome; and thanks so much for joining our discussion, Kerri.

    Reply

     

     

Vera Marie Badertscher says:

Although the safety on airplanes is an interesting thought, I don’t imagine it will motivate too many people to lose weight. But wouldn’t it be nice if the people who really NEED to know about BMI would do the math on their own bodies?

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    Well, Vera, maybe with enough public awareness, they will!?

    Reply

     

     

merr says:

I remember a long time ago taking a puddle jumper from Tucson to Phoenix (maybe) to catch a jet plane to LA. The pilot asked every single passenger (there were, I think, 6 or 8 of us) our weight and sat us accordingly to balance it out. I think this was before people were using the term BMI.

Reply

 

 

Irene says:

That’s amazing data about airplanes. Sage advice too. Thanks for sharing!

Reply

 

 

ruth pennebaker says:

Flying tomorrow — and will be checking out other passengers’ bmi. Just something else to worry about!

Reply

 

 

Casey says:

The average woman weighs 165 pounds? That’s a sobering statistic!

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    Agreed, Casey. It is indeed sobering, especially when you realize that it has increased through the years and seems to keep climbing.

    Reply

     

     

Donna Hull says:

I’ve read that many parts of our lives are having to be redesigned because so many people have high BMI. Think hospital beds, stretchers, ambulances, etc. I never thought about the danger of flying with an overweight person, only the discomfort of sitting next to them.

Reply

 

 

Rosalba Gordon says:

Thanks for this post, I’ll be aware of my BMI, I didn’t know anything about!

Reply

 

 

Alexandra says:

I find it is so much harder to take off the weight over 60. I run a B&B and we had some overweight guests arrive today. My chairs are not made for the obese, neither for those who weigh more than they should. I worry they will break and I will be liable. This is similar to the airplane seat connundrum. Should the airlines provide huge seats so most Americans can fit into them?? I think the obesity epidemic comes from the lousy food available in supermarkets. Processed food has no nutrition. We eat it and put on weight.

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    That’s an interesting thought, Alexandra. I do wonder if you’d be liable if a guest fell off a chair – but I suppose anyone could fall (although I do understand the difference if the chair breaks due to too much weight on it). I do wonder if that’s a question for your insurance company…

    Reply

     

     

Jeremy says:

Thanks for the interesting information and a good read, too!

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    Thanks, Jeremy. And thanks for being the one lone male to be brave enough to leave a comment!

    Reply

     

     

Jeanine Barone says:

As a nutritionist, I’m well acquainted with BMI but I just have never thought it’s practical for the average overweight or obese person. After all, whether they get on a scale or look at their own bulging waist line or hips, I think they would know they need to lose weight. And, yes, regular exercise and controlling portion size and calorie intake in general is key. But it’s amazing how people come up with all manner excuses why they don’t have time to exercise and why they like eating fatty foods and can’t stomach eating anything healthy.

Reply

 

 

Sheryl says:

thanks for weighing in on this, Jeanine. It’s nice to have the perspective of a nutritionist. And I am aware that BMI is difficult for the average overweight or obese person. The scale – and a bulging waist – is indeed a good reliable indicator of the need to take off some weight.
And I couldn’t agree more – that people do come up with lost of excuses about their weight, when eating right and exercising are good and available options to anyone, given the desire.

Reply

 

 

Jane Boursaw says:

BMI has always been a confusing mystery to me. Thanks for the primer. Clicking through to calculate mine (if I’m brave enough).

Reply

 

 

Roxanne says:

My doc calculated mine and said it was normal, normal, normal. Kind of nice to hear once in a while. (smirk)

Reply

 

 

Kristen says:

I just wanted to add that BMIs are tough to calculate for teens–with their grow spurts, etc., it’s much trickier. I’m glad you pointed out that it can differ for adolescents and older people. I don’t bother with BMIs or the scale anymore, I rely *gulp* on the measuring tape instead.

Reply

 

 

    Sheryl says:

    Absolutely different in adolescents/teens. And the gold old-fashioned measuring tape was once a very reliable tool; I’d imagine it still is. It doesn’t lie, it can’t run out of batteries…what you see is what you get (are)!

    Reply

     

     

Kris says:

Next, please address “visceral abdominal fat” in peri-menopausal women. ;)

Reply

 

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

 

 

We welcome and encourage your comments on the Supplemental, and hope you will join the discussions. In accordance with our social media policy, we review comments and reserve the right to remove those that are off-topic or focus on a commercial product. We also expect a basic level of mutual respect, and while disagreements are fine, profanity or abusive language will not be tolerated.